• No More This than That : Pyrrhonian Indeterminacy Vogt, Katja Maria 2021 Midwest Studies in Philosophy , Vol. 45 , S. 57 ff. ( Zeitschrift ) Englisch 0363-6550 | 1475-4975 10.5840/msp202111416 Abstract

    In the terms of ancient epistemology, Pyrrho is a dogmatist, not a skeptic, simply on account of putting forward a metaphysical theory. His most contested claim is that things are indifferent, unmeasured, and indeterminate—or, on a competing reconstruction, that things are indifferentiable, unmeasurable, and indeterminable. This paper argues that Pyrrho’s position, which I call Pyrrhonian Indeterminacy, belongs to a rich tradition of revisionist metaphysics that includes ancient atomism, flux metaphysics, Plato’s analysis of becoming, and today’s discussions of indeterminacy and vagueness. This tradition, my argument continues, makes room for a kind of metaphysics that proceeds in epistemological terms. Pyrrho’s indeterminacy claim says that things are indeterminate insofar as they do not have features by reference to which we can determine them to be such-and-such. We should not waver or be inclined to see things one way or another—we should see things, and describe them, as “no more this than that.”


    Analytic Philosophy | Contemporary Philosophy

Vogt, Katja Maria
Analytic Philosophy
Contemporary Philosophy

  • keine externen Weblinks